Best Pizza Shop Loyalty Programs in 2026: 5 tools compared
Updated 4 min read
Pizza shops sell a lot through online ordering, phone and delivery, not just at the counter. The best program counts every order, wherever it was placed.
Our pick
Revio
Best overall
- Wallet passes: customers join in seconds without installing an app
- Points, stamp cards, tiers, partner rewards, Spin to Win and leaderboards in one product
- Push notifications and targeted campaigns, including bonus-point challenges for quiet hours
The shortlist
1. Revio
Best overall
Best for cafés, restaurants, salons and shops that want points, stamps and tiers in one place.
What it is: A loyalty platform for local businesses, from revio.so. Points, rewards, stamp cards, tiers, referrals, campaigns and member activity live in one workspace, and customers join through an Apple Wallet or Google Wallet pass, with no app to download.
Strengths
- Wallet passes: customers join in seconds without installing an app
- Points, stamp cards, tiers, partner rewards, Spin to Win and leaderboards in one product
- Push notifications and targeted campaigns, including bonus-point challenges for quiet hours
- Rewards for referrals, reviews and social engagement
- Analytics on earning, redemptions and engagement
Limitations
- Built for physical locations, not for online-only e-commerce stores
- Pricing is quote-based: you book a demo to get a price
- No POS integration yet, so points are added outside your checkout rather than automatically
Pricing: Custom, via demo (checked 2026-11-09)
2. Toast Loyalty
Best for Toast POS restaurants
Best for restaurants already running Toast POS.
What it is: The loyalty program built into Toast, the restaurant POS. Guests earn points for dollars spent or visits, and points are tracked automatically with each purchase in-store and online.
Strengths
- Guests enrol at the register, from a digital receipt, when ordering online or from a sign-up link
- Points by spend or by visit, with rewards from free items to cash back
- Bonus rules like double-point days or extra points for takeout, plus birthday and welcome rewards
- Works with Toast Online Ordering, Toast Website and Toast Email Marketing
Limitations
- Only for restaurants on the Toast POS platform
- Toast doesn’t publish a Loyalty price: you get it through a demo
- Wallet passes, tiers and referrals are not mentioned
Pricing: Add-on to Toast POS; price via a Toast demo (checked 2026-11-10)
3. Square Loyalty
Best for Square POS users
Best for businesses already running Square POS.
What it is: The loyalty program built into Square. Customers earn points at the Square register, on Square Online or through Square Invoices, and points sit in the same customer directory as your sales.
Strengths
- Points by visit, by amount spent or by item and category
- VIP tiers with 1.5x, 2x and 3x points
- Customers enroll at the register with a phone number, and points count even on cash payments
- Automatic texts when customers earn points or rewards, plus bonus-point promotions
- Loyalty sales show up in Square reporting with no extra integration
Limitations
- Tied to Square: earning works through Square POS, Square Online and Square Invoices
- Apple Wallet pass is mentioned; Google Wallet is not
- Loyalty needs Square Plus at $49/mo per location; the free Square plan doesn’t include it
Pricing: Included in Square Plus, $49/mo per location, which also adds email and text marketing; 30-day free trial (checked 2026-11-09)
4. BonusQR
Best free plan
Best for small businesses that want a real free plan and no POS integration.
What it is: A QR-based loyalty app for small businesses. Customers join in one click, get a personal QR code (in the web app, the BonusQR app or Apple and Google Wallet) and staff scan it with a phone.
Strengths
- Free forever plan with unlimited customers and stamp cards, cashback and visit rewards
- No POS needed: staff scan the customer’s QR code with a phone
- Paid plans add points, tiered stamp cards, referrals, push and email news, booking and an e-shop
- Shopify, WooCommerce and Zapier on paid plans
Limitations
- The free plan has one login and no push or email messages
- Referrals and tiered cashback need the $71/mo Premium plan
- No named POS integrations on the standard plans
Pricing: Free; Basic $20/mo; Premium $71/mo (billed quarterly, prices vary by country) (checked 2026-11-10)
5. Boomerangme
Best for many card types
Best for multi-location businesses and agencies that want many wallet card types and SMS.
What it is: A wallet loyalty platform for local businesses and agencies. Customers add a card to Apple or Google Wallet, and staff add stamps and points with a free browser-based scanner app.
Strengths
- Many card types: stamps, points, cashback, tiered rewards, memberships, discounts, coupons and gift cards
- Unlimited free push notifications, including geo-fenced pushes near your store
- Push, SMS and email automations
- Zapier, Make and Shopify connections, plus an API and webhooks
Limitations
- Expensive for one shop: plans start at $164/mo billed yearly ($199 monthly)
- No free plan, only a 14-day trial
- POS integrations are listed on the Franchise plan without naming specific systems
Pricing: Business $199/mo ($164/mo yearly), Agency $259/mo, Franchise $299/mo, Enterprise custom; 14-day free trial (checked 2026-11-10)
Side-by-side comparison
| Tool | Starting price | Free trial | Wallet passes | Stamp cards | Tiers | Referrals | Messaging | POS integrations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revio | Custom pricing | Via demo | Apple + Google | Yes | Yes | Yes | Push, campaigns | None; runs alongside any POS |
| Toast Loyalty | Quote via Toast | Via demo | Not listed | Visit-based points | Not listed | Not listed | Email via Toast Marketing | Toast only |
| Square Loyalty | $49/mo | 30-day trial | Apple only | Visit-based points | Yes (3 tiers) | Not listed | Texts, email (in Plus) | Square only |
| BonusQR | Free, then $20/mo | Free plan | Apple + Google | Yes | Premium plan | Premium plan | Push, email (paid) | None needed; Shopify, Zapier |
| Boomerangme | $164/mo | 14-day trial | Apple + Google | Yes | Yes | Yes | Push, SMS, email | Zapier, Make, Shopify |
What to look for
- 01
Every order counts
Check that takeout and online orders earn points, not just walk-ins. POS programs like Toast and Square track this automatically.
- 02
Offers for slow nights
A double-points Tuesday or a bonus on takeout fills the quiet nights most pizzerias have.
- 03
Sign-up at the counter
If joining takes more than a few seconds, most customers skip it. Wallet passes and QR codes beat apps that need a download and an account.
- 04
Price for one location
Compare what a single location pays per month, then what changes as you add locations, customers or orders.
What it costs
Here is what each tool costs a single pizzeria.
- Revio: Custom, via demo
- Toast Loyalty: Add-on to Toast POS; price via a Toast demo
- Square Loyalty: Included in Square Plus, $49/mo per location, which also adds email and text marketing; 30-day free trial
- BonusQR: Free; Basic $20/mo; Premium $71/mo (billed quarterly, prices vary by country)
- Boomerangme: Business $199/mo ($164/mo yearly), Agency $259/mo, Franchise $299/mo, Enterprise custom; 14-day free trial
How to choose
- Choose Revio if you want one wallet card that handles points, stamps, tiers and referrals, with push campaigns to bring customers back.
- Choose Toast Loyalty if you run a restaurant on Toast POS and want loyalty tied to every order.
- Choose Square Loyalty if you already take payments on Square and want loyalty inside the same system.
- Choose BonusQR if you want a real free plan and no POS integration, with staff scanning customers’ QR codes.
- Choose Boomerangme if you run several locations or an agency and want many wallet card types with push, SMS and email.
The verdict
Revio is our pick for pizza shops that want wallet cards, points and campaigns for slow nights. If you take orders through Toast or Square, their built-in programs count online and in-store orders automatically. BonusQR is a free way to start, and Boomerangme adds SMS and email.
How we compared
- Customer sign-up: how fast a customer can join at the counter, and whether they need an app.
- Setup: time from signup to the first customer earning a reward.
- Rewards and marketing: points, stamps, tiers, referrals and ways to reach quiet customers.
- Pricing: what a single location pays per month.
- Features: wallet passes, POS integrations and reporting.
Rankings weight what decides whether customers come back over feature counts. Read the full method.
Related guides
Prices and features come from each vendor's own website, checked November 10, 2026.